The table below details both total harmonic distortion limit and individual harmonic limit on the voltage for a number of major classification societies, namely DNV, ABS, RS and KR:
Classification Society | THDU limit | Individual harmonic limit | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
DNV Det Norske Veritas | < 8 % | < 5 % | Rules for classification: Ships (Oct. 2019) Part 4, Chapter 8, Section 2, 1.2.7 |
ABS American Bureau of Shipping | < 8 % | < 5 % | Rules for Building and Classing Steel Vessels (Jul. 2019) Part 4, Chapter 8, Section 2, 7.21 |
BV Bureau Veritas | < 8 % | ≤ 15th: 5 %, then falling logarithmic to 1 % at 100th | Rules for Classification of Steel Ships (Jan. 2020) Part C, Chapter 2, Section 2, 2.4.2 |
LR Lloyd’s Register | < 8 % | None of the harmonics above 25th shall exceed 1.5 % | Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Ships (July 2019) Part 6, Chapter 2, Section 1, 1.8.3 |
RINA Registro Italiano Navale | < 10 % | ≤ 15th: 5 %, then falling logarithmic to 1 % at 100th | Rules for the Classification of Ships (Jan. 2020) Part C, Chapter 2, Section 2, 2.2.2 |
CCS China Classification Society | < 10 % | ≤ 15th: 5 %, then falling linearly to 1 % at 100th | Rules for Classification of Sea-Going Ships (Jul. 2018) Part 8, Chapter 15.2.2.2 |
RS Russian Maritime Register of Shipping | < 10 % | ≤ 15th: < 10 % 16th – 99th: falling logarithmic to 1 % 100th – 200th: < 1 % | Rules for the Classification and Construction of Sea-Going Ships (Jan. 2020) Part XI, Section 2.2.1 |
KR Korean Register | < 8 % | < 3 % | Rules for the Classification of Steel Ships (2019) Part 6, Chapter 1, Section 8 |
Note that DNV, ABS and KR all have individual harmonic limit that is not dependent of harmonic order – which means that the maximum of 5 % of for example DNV applies equally at 5th harmonic as well as at 49th harmonic! Surely, 5 % is much more damaging at higher harmonic orders. CCS, BV, RINA and RS circumvents this by specifying a falling curve from 15th harmonic to 100th harmonic – linear curve for CCS and logarithmic for BV, RINA and RS. Also note that CCS specifies the curve until infinite harmonic order, which technically makes it impossible to determine compliance, as no instrument have infinite bandwidth!